Rethinking the “Overqualified” Candidate

Rethinking the “Overqualified” Candidate
By Lyn Kleinbach-Reilly, Founder, The Kleinbach Group

Everyone seems to have strong opinions about “overqualified” candidates. Some believe it’s just code for insecurity. Others believe it’s a legitimate retention concern.

After more than 30 years in recruiting, I think the answer is more nuanced.

If someone with exceptional experience wants to join your company, dismissing them because they might leave in 18 months feels shortsighted. In today’s world, 18 months is a long time.

Products change.
Markets shift.
Strategies evolve.
Entire companies can look different in less time than that.

So perhaps the better question isn’t, “How long will they stay?”

It’s, “What could they accomplish while they’re here?”

Could they build a function?
Mentor future leaders?
Create systems that outlast their tenure?
Help the company avoid costly mistakes?

In The Soul of Recruiting, I write about hiring for contribution, not just longevity.

The best hiring decisions aren’t made from fear. They’re made by honestly assessing the value someone can create and whether that value aligns with what the business needs now.

Sometimes the answer is no. But sometimes an extraordinary 18 months changes the trajectory of a company.

That’s worth thinking about.

If this resonates, The Soul of Recruiting digs into how to hire for contribution, not just longevity.

Add Comment

Contact Us